Book Reviews by Sondra Eklund |
Buy from Amazon.com
Rate this Book Sonderbooks 87 Previous Book Next Book Nonfiction Biographical Previous Book Next Book Fiction Young Adult Fiction Children's Nonfiction Children's Fiction Picture Books 2004 Stand-outs Previous Book Next Book 2003 Stand-outs 2002 Stand-outs 2001 Stand-outs Five-Star Books Four-Star Books PreviousBook Next Book Old Favorites Back Issues List of Reviews by Title List of Reviews by Author Why Read? Children and Books Links For Book Lovers Book Discussion Forum About Me Contact Me Subscribe Make a Donation I don't review books I don't like! *****= An all-time favorite |
****Journey from the Land of NoA Girlhood Caught in Revolutionary Iranby Roya Hakakian Reviewed October 26, 2004.
Crown Publishers, New York, 2004. 245 pages. Sonderbooks Stand-out 2004, #8, Personal Stories and Reflections In Journey from the Land of No, Roya Hakakian tells of her childhood as a Jew in Iran. She shows us that politics in Iran wasn’t as simple as many Americans seem to think. The Jews in her community loved Iran and saw it as their homeland. Yet many of them supported the Ayatollah because he promised to bring freedom. Roya Hakakian grew up learning that it wasn’t safe to express certain opinions. She was happy, along with most Iranians, when the Shah was deposed. Then came changes. Her school was given an Islamic principal who explained to the girls why it was important that men should never see a strand of their hair. This book is poetically told. Roya Hakakian explains to us the valued place of poetry in Persian society, and we can see the poetry implicit in her prose. My summary of the issues involved doesn’t do the book justice. She presents the history in scenes from her life, as a little girl grew up and watched her country change. She does leave us with a sadness for the Muslim women friends she left behind. One such friend said good-by to her with the words: “‘You’re lucky, Roya. You’re a Jew. Once you leave Iran, you’ll get a visa to any country in the world. But where can I go?’ “‘But I don’t want to go anywhere else,’ I said, though I knew my objection made me no less lucky in her eyes.’ “‘You must go,’ she continued. ‘Go soon! Leave and never look back.’” Roya did go to America with her family soon after that. We are all richer now that she has chosen to look back. Copyright © 2005 Sondra Eklund. All
rights reserved. |