Sonderbooks Book Reviews by Sondra Eklund

Buy from

Rate this Book

Sonderbooks 106
    Previous Book
    Next Book

Young Adult Fiction
        Previous Book
        Next Book

Children's Nonfiction
Children's Fiction
Picture Books

2005 Stand-outs
2004 Stand-outs
2003 Stand-outs
2002 Stand-outs
2001 Stand-outs

Five-Star Books
Four-Star Books
Old Favorites
Back Issues
List of Reviews by Title
List of Reviews by Author

Why Read?
Children and Books
Links For Book Lovers
Book Discussion Forum

About Me
Contact Me
Make a Donation

I don't review books I don't like!

*****= An all-time favorite
****  = Outstanding
***    = Above average
**      = Enjoyable
*        = Good, with reservations


***First Impressions

by Marilyn Sachs

Reviewed April 24, 2006.
A Deborah Brodie Book, Roaring Brook Press, New Milford Connecticut, 2006.  117 pages.
Available at Sembach Library (J MCN F SAC).

This book is on the young end of young adult fiction.  It opens when 15-year-old straight-A student Alice gets a C+ on her paper on Pride and Prejudice.  She feels that the book is a tragedy, since Mary, the middle child (just like Alice) finds no love in her life like her sisters do.

Alice is also the third of five sisters, so she sympathizes with Mary, who’s simply a target of humor in Jane Austen’s book.  Alice gets a chance to rewrite her paper over Christmas break, and a nice boy named Kevin offers to help her with it.  (Are there really fifteen-year-old boys out there who would like Pride and Prejudice so much that they’d go to the library to check out another Jane Austen book?  I don’t really believe that.)

Alice takes another look at the book and tries to give Mary a happier ending.  Meanwhile, she goes on her first date and seems to be getting her first boyfriend.  Pride and Prejudice makes her look at all this differently, and she ends up as a fan.

I didn’t really believe the set-up.  In the first place, I think Alice’s taking Mary’s perspective was very creative, and a teacher shouldn’t grade her down simply because she didn’t agree with the conclusion.  She should be graded on how well she supported her own point of view.  Next, I don’t really believe how much Kevin likes Pride and Prejudice, and he’s not portrayed as showing enthusiasm simply to impress Alice.  Finally, I don’t see why Alice would like the book so much the second time if she hadn’t liked it the first time.

However, I’m a sucker for these Jane Austen take-offs.  I have three more of them checked out and ready to read!  They seem to be all the rage, ever since The Jane Austen Book Club was a bestseller.  It was fun to read one for a younger age group.  I would have liked Alice’s own romance to have some of the mistaken impressions as in the romance in Pride and Prejudice.  But it was still a fun and quick read.


Copyright © 2006 Sondra Eklund.  All rights reserved.

-top of page-