The Tenth Mistake of Hank HoopermanReview posted September 17, 2024.
Greenwillow Books, September 2024. 345 pages.
Review written August 13, 2024, from a library book.
Starred Review
Okay, disclaimer first. My timing with this book was most unfortunate. I read this one immediately after finishing And Then... Boom! by Lisa Fipps. The books set up a plot that is way too similar - both involving a mother who abandons her kids and a grandma who dies. Okay, in this one, Grandma died (recently) before the start of the book, but together with Louder than Hunger, by John Schu, which I read earlier this year, I've had quite enough of Grandmas dying, thank you very much! Can we put a pause on that?
This book and And Then... Boom! are both excellent middle grade novels, dealing with a super hard topic that honestly should be dealt with, and both do it well. But I do *not* recommend reading the books back-to-back. Both end happily, as they absolutely need to do for a middle grade audience, but both main characters go through a kid's worst nightmare - the abandonment by their own mother, and having to face that their own mother is not responsible enough to take care of them.
The books are different. I prefer prose to novels in verse, because you get more detail, so I liked this one a little bit better, but I would not want to be on the Newbery committee this year, because I suspect there will be arguments about which one is more distinguished, and have a feeling some will gravitate to one and some to the other. (I could be totally wrong about this.)
Anyway, this book I read has a big bright spot in the character of Boo, Hank Hooperman's three-year-old sister. It's because of Boo, well, that and an eviction notice, that twelve-year-old Hank can't keep trying to go it alone after his mother leaves and doesn't come back.
So after some effort to figure out what in the world to do, Hank looks up the name Mom put on his field trip permission slip as an Emergency Contact, and it's Lou Ann, a lady who was friends with his Grandma.
Lou Ann is happy to take care of Boo - she even does day care for preschoolers out of her home - but she isn't so happy about taking care of Hank. She contacts Child Protective Services and gets Hank and Boo caseworkers. Meanwhile, while they're trying to find Hank's Mom and wondering how long Lou Ann will put them up, Hank attends a new school in the district where Lou Ann lives. He makes new friends and gets recruited for the basketball team, but he doesn't want to tell anyone why he's not sure how long he'll stay.
Once again, let me assure you that it does end happy -- because it would all be way too much to take if it didn't. In many ways, it's a tough read, and Hank is a kid you just want to make things better for. I kind of hate that Hank is hyperaware of the mistakes he makes because, doggone it, a kid shouldn't have to have so much responsibility, and his mother doesn't seem to be aware of her own mistakes at all.
So, yes, this is a powerful book, with characters you'll care about, and believe it or not, plenty of humor and kindness to get you through the hard things. But be ready for some gut wrenching along the way.