The Unselected Journals of Emma M. Lion

Volume 5

by Beth Brower

Review posted September 29, 2024.
Rhydon Press, 2021. 251 pages.
Review written August 1, 2024, from my own copy, purchased via amazon.com.
Starred Review

With each volume of these "Unselected Journals" I read, I get more and more obsessed. When I finished volume 5, I was sad that I only currently own two more volumes. (She's writing more, though!)

This is historical fiction about a young woman in London in 1883, in this volume from November to December. She's on the periphery of society, an orphan who's going to come into her inheritance next month, but who still is supposed to act like a proper young lady - something she gets away with fudging.

But these books are way more than a simple romance novel. I love the deep friendships she is building with no less than three young single gentlemen. In this volume, Emma is dealing with having finally attended the burial of the man she'd loved, who died three years ago in Afghanistan. She read his good-by letter, and it's hard to move on. All her friends - including those three men - are extra kind and compassionate toward her in this book.

And with that serious note, the book also has all sorts of humorous and quirky bits throughout. Emma is trying to track the Roman ghost that frequents her neighborhood - and gets reactions from everyone who knows about it. She delivers the second favor she owes to the scoundrel Jack, and it's surprising. Her friend the artist comes back from Italy, and her friend Mary has more adventures in London - so it's not like Emma hangs around only with young men. I also love Agnes, Emma's cook and housekeeper, who in this volume wants to get into the St. Crispian's Society for Senior Servants. And then there's the marvelous Mrs. Penury, who has decided that she's got nothing more to say, and keeps delightful company with people in complete silence.

The fact that these are presented as journals makes the episodic bits completely believable and fun. I've always loved a slow-burn romance. But watching Emma's friendships grow and deepen with three different young men over time takes this to the next level. My only trouble at this point is I don't want any of them to get their hearts broken. But I'm for sure looking forward to watching things continue.

I'm going to try to read another book before I eagerly pick up the next volume, but I'm making no promises.