Love at Second SightReview posted June 2, 2026.
Simon & Schuster Audio, 2025. 11 hours, 41 minutes.
Review written May 29, 2026, from a library eaudiobook.
Starred Review
I love F. T. Lukens' books! An Kevin R. Free reading them has gotten me feeling like I'm listening to a story told by a lovable friend.
Love at Second Sight is set in a world just like ours - except magic and paranormal abilities are completely normal. And so is being queer. In fact, queer is probably not the right term to use, because nobody bats an eye at Cam, our protagonist, having a crush on another boy. And everybody is fine with Cam's best friend Al using they/them pronouns. People are cool with Al's two moms.
But paranormal abilities, though all around them, are not quite as accepted by people like Cam's parents. They're hoping that for Cam's Sophomore year of high school, he'll make some new friends and spend less time with Al, who's a witch. Cam doesn't tell them about his crush on a werewolf. He's starting at a new high school that has a much higher percentage of paranormal students than his old one.
And that first day of Sophomore year does not go well. First some little things go wrong, and then he gets stuck in the middle of a large fight between werewolves and sprites in the middle of a hall. He gets thrown against some lockers, and while he's out cold, he has a vision of a girl who's been stabbed and seems to be dying, and Cam in the vision is holding a bloody knife in his hands.
As things develop, it turns out that Cam has a paranormal gift that's incredibly rare - he's a clairvoyant who gets true visions of the future when someone touches him.
But that brings up the questions: Who touched him in the hallway? Who is the bloody girl? Can he warn her and save her life? And can he keep his parents from finding out?
After a video of Cam having another clairvoyant vision goes viral, Cam gathers a hodgepodge team of friends who help him deal with his new fame and help him identify the girl and try to save her. At the same time, all the various paranormal guilds and factions want to recruit him to form an exclusive relationship with them and give them an advantage over any adversaries.
There are plenty of obstacles and angst along the way, as well as time with that werewolf Cam has a crush on. The book is full of suspense with a mystery to solve, but plenty of humor to go along with it. And you can't help feeling for a kid who thought he was a normal human suddenly having paranormal powers everybody wants a piece of.
Although the book is completely absorbing as a story and was not written as a parable, there are some parallels between how Cam is treated with paranormal abilities and how queer people are treated in our world. Those added resonance and made some horrible reactions feel all too believable. This also made me all the more satisfied with the lovely happy ending. This book left me smiling.