Review posted February 28, 2026.
Quill Tree Books, 2024. 353 pages.
Review written December 29, 2025, from a library book.
2026 Mathical Book Prize Honor Book, Grades 9-12
Here's a light-hearted novel about a senior in high school who's trying to get out of her comfort zone for the sake of her Stanford application.
And of course there's guy drama. Brian was her best friend in middle school before he moved away. When Aisha got a scholarship to the same private high school Brian attends, he turned out to have become hot. But he also barely acknowledges Aisha's existence, despite her growing crush. So when the picture in his locker of his girlfriend comes down - and he asks Aisha to the winter formal, she thinks her dreams have come true.
But when she arrives at winter formal, she doesn't see him anywhere. And then his mother - of all people - calls Aisha to say that Brian is sick with the flu. Aisha flees the festivities, but doesn't know who to call to get a ride home. Her mother didn't even know she'd planned to be there with a boy. She's standing next to a clarinet player from a jazz band who happens to be her best friend's boyfriend's grandmother. The grandma is waiting for a promised ride from her friend's grandson, who hasn't shown up. So she has some wise words for Aisha about being stood up.
But the grandma doesn't keep waiting around and calls a cab. Shortly after she leaves, a kid pulls up in a Volkswagen Jetta, apologizes for being late, and tells her to hop in. Clearly he's mistaken Aisha for the clarinet player, but in the spirit of the advice she's been given, Aisha hops in.
But before long the story comes out. This guy, Quentin, is a good listener. Since Aisha's all dressed up, they go for ice cream, and eventually reach a deal: Aisha will tutor Quentin in precalculus, so he won't fail, and Quentin will help coach Aisha into doing activities outside her comfort zone for the Stanford application and to actually live life. And yes, her goals get transferred to sticky notes.
So that's the set-up. And yes, it plays out with the reader understanding that Aisha's got a crush on the wrong guy long before she does. Quentin ends up having a lot more back story than came out at first, and we've got friend drama, high school drama, family drama - all in a sweet feel-good story that makes you care about this girl who cares a little bit too much about getting into Stanford. Reading about the things that wake her up is a heart-warming ride with a set of delightful people.
