Threads That BindReview posted May 8, 2024
Listening Library, 2023. 12 hours.
Review written February 20, 2024, from a library eaudiobook.
Starred Review
2023 CYBILS Award Winner, Young Adult Speculative Fiction
This year I was Category Chair for the CYBILS Awards Young Adult Speculative Fiction category, but because I was reading for the Morris Award, I didn't get to take part as a judge or panelist. So I'm making up for lost time and reading the great books they picked.
Threads That Bind is a distinctive fantasy. It's set in a world after an apocalypse with separate city-states divided by barren wastelands in between. In the city of Silts, where tides regularly flood, Io has grown up with her two sisters, all of them descendants of the Fates, the Mira. Like all Otherborn, the Miraborn have inherited powers. All three can see people's life threads, the connections between people and the things or people they love, including life itself. The oldest can weave the threads, the next can draw the threads, and the third, Io in this family, can cut the threads.
As the book opens, Io is doing work as a private investigator, afraid she'll have to report that her client's husband is indeed having an affair, and she can see by the strong thread between him and his lover that they are in love. But then a person shows up and attacks and kills him. This person is alive, but shouldn't be alive -- because she has only one thread, her life thread, and it's been cut.
But someone shows up at the crime scene -- and it's the person Io's been avoiding -- the boy she shares a Fate thread with, before she'd even met him. His name's Edei, and he works for the Mob Queen who rules their city. The Mob Queen orders Io to investigate this wraith, because it's not the first one to show up in the Silts. Who is making this happen, and how are they choosing their victims, while talking about justice?
What follows is a long and somewhat convoluted investigation, trying to find out who's behind it all and what they are plotting. Io must talk with many different Otherborn and dig around lots of people with power -- including the new mayoral candidate -- and her oldest sister, who abandoned them years before.
Like I said, the plot seemed a little convoluted to me -- but the problem may have been that I didn't listen closely enough. The magic system is intriguing, but I had to not look at the details too closely. (If Miraborn always come in sets of three, why are they not triplets? What happens if the third is never born? And why are all the threads not hopelessly tangled up?) I also didn't completely understand all the motivations revealed at the end, having to do with the Gang War many years ago.
But all the same, it's a great story also looking at questions of emotional abuse, justice, and violence. Although the book does solve the mysteries presented, there's an overarching story that isn't finished yet. I just checked and see that Book Two, Hearts That Cut, is coming out in June, and I've already ordered copies for the library.