Throne of GlassReview posted August 24, 2024
Bloomsbury Publishing, 2021. 13 hours, 4 minutes.
Review written August 19, 2024, from a library eaudiobook.
Sarah J. Maas's books are wildly popular at our library, so that we've hit the cap on some of the ebooks and can't keep up with the holds list. I decided to see what all the fuss is about and started in on the Throne of Glass series. I followed the order I found online and read the prequel novellas, collected in The Assassin's Blade first, which may have taken a little bit of mystery from the main character, Celaena Sardothien, in this book. But I don't think it was a bad thing to already know her and be impressed with her skills. I also know her history and the people she reasonably holds grudges against - though she doesn't know who betrayed her and sent her into slavery in the mines, and I do.
At the start of this book, the prince of the empire has taken 18-year-old Celaena out of the mines, where she's been slaving for a year, surviving despite the high odds against that. The prince tells her she has a chance to win her freedom. He is sponsoring her in a contest to determine the king's champion. If she loses, she'll have to go back to the mines. If she wins, she'll have to serve the brutal king - responsible for killing her parents when his army destroyed her people - for four years as champion.
So the stakes are high. I already knew about Celaena's incredible skills, so her confidence didn't feel misplaced to me, but she's up against some powerful opponents, and she has plenty of work to do to prepare. On top of that, contestants begin dying - killed brutally with their insides ripped out.
Celaena does have allies in the palace. The prince chose her because he knew it would anger his father. He has put his captain of the guard in charge of monitoring her progress. And Celaena befriends a visiting princess, whose language she learned in the mines, where so many of those who spoke it were also enslaved.
The story is absorbing with its high-stakes contest. I'd heard that Sarah Maas's books have explicit sex, but not this series, or at least not this book. There is some kissing, but not a lot. In fact, the book seems to be setting up a love triangle, but that kind of fizzles out at the end, and I'm expecting more to develop in one side of that triangle in the next book.
Although I did enjoy the book, it hit a number of my pet peeves. Not badly enough that I stopped listening (as I have been known to do), but enough that I'm withholding a star. The first was the terrible king with a noble prince for a son trope. Yes, the king is awful, responsible for the deaths of thousands - but the prince is different. Really!
The second pet peeve this book hit was the Noble Thief trope. Someone was forced into living a life of crime, but they're good at heart and when good things happen we all cheer. Disney's Aladdin popularized this one. In this book, our main character isn't a thief - she's an assassin. An incredibly skilled assassin, the best in the kingdom, at seventeen years old. She knows multiple ways to kill people with her bare hands - and yet it's not her fault. She was taken in by an assassin and forced to learn the trade. And she learned it well, so that despite her small size, she can kill almost anyone. And she's good at heart. Really!
The third one was about writing style. The point of view didn't stick with the main character, but dipped into other heads here and there. It wasn't often enough to really make them viewpoint characters, and it felt a little undisciplined. Tied in with that, the writing felt a little overdramatic. Yeah, sure, she's the best assassin ever. A little more telling than showing. Though it's possible that was from the way the narrator read it - but I think it was in the words themselves.
Despite all this, I think I'm going to continue with the series (though I may have to wait until after this year's Cybils Awards to read on). Celaena is growing on me. I think there are six more books in the series, and I'm hoping eventually the brutal king will get his comeuppance. Also, Celaena's been through a lot. I'd already love to see her find love and friendship. And have her loved one not die horribly right away. Though I do have a feeling she's in for a lot more trouble first.