Category: Stand-outs

I’m celebrating my 25th year of writing Sonderbooks with #Sonderbooks25!

Tonight I’ll be looking back at my Sonderbooks Stand-outs from 2002.

Now, I confess that when I announced my #Sonderbooks25 project, I expected to post every couple weeks, not every few months. So let me start with some excuses.

First, my original plan was to simply read the reviews of the Stand-outs for each year and choose one book to reread and reflect on that every couple of weeks. I knew the first five years, 2001-2005, would take a little longer, because I also planned to reformat the Stand-outs pages.

What I didn’t realize was that once I’d gotten started, I’d want to reread every review I’d written during the year in question. For 2002, that was before the blog when I was still producing numbered issues, and covers Sonderbooks #19 through Sonderbooks #44. You can find all the Back Issues on the Back Issues Index page. Reading all of them, I think I did a good job picking out Stand-outs, as those are indeed the books I most want to revisit. But that wasn’t even enough for me. I also reread the posts from Project 52 from the year I was 37 and the year I was 38.

So I do have reasons to take a long time between posts. And it turns out, though my 2025 Sonderbooks Stand-outs page will be my 25th list of Stand-outs, I won’t hit the actual 25th birthday of Sonderbooks until August 1st, 2026. So there’s not really a big rush. All that said, it took me an especially long time to post about the 2002 Sonderbooks Stand-outs because of two additional complications.

1) I was writing a weekly blog series over on Sonderjourneys called “Laments for Lent.” It turns out that doing significant blogging more than once a week is tricky, especially because:

2) I broke my left pinky finger seven weeks ago, and it hurt to use my left hand at all for a few weeks, and that seriously slowed down my typing. (I finally see the doctor next Monday and hope to stop buddy-taping it. But I predict it will still be a while before my typing’s back up to speed.)

Okay, that’s probably enough excuses! Tonight I updated the links and my new version of my 2002 Sonderbooks Stand-outs is live.

Let me talk about the books in the order they appear on the original page.

From Young Adult and Children’s Fantasy, the stand-out of the Stand-outs is This Star Shall Abide, by Sylvia Louise Engdahl. Another that stands out is Heir Apparent, by Vivian Vande Velde, which I bought for my kids and both of them (or at least the younger?) enjoyed. The rest were all very good, but don’t make me quite as nostalgic. Though I’d reread them all if I could find the time (and if I weren’t trying to move on to books reviewed in 2003).

Among the Young Adult and Children’s Fantasy Rereads, The Blue Sword, by Robin McKinley, is still quite possibly my all-time favorite book (though it’s so hard to narrow it down to one!). I have reread it many times, though, so I didn’t feel as compelled to make it my one Reread for 2002 – though, Ha! I checked just now and my library has it in eaudiobook form, so I just placed a hold.

The Harry Potter books are Alas! tainted by the fact that their author has revealed herself to be a transphobic bigot. But the other in that category, Ella Enchanted, by Gail Carson Levine, is completely delightful, and – Oh look! We’ve got that in eaudiobook form, too.

For Young Adult Historical Fiction, I don’t remember any of the three titles distinctly, except to be sure I’d enjoy rereading them. And as for the “Rereads” – The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle, by Avi, is among my all-time favorites, and I’ve reread it many times. (Oh look! That one’s on eaudio, too!) As for Treasure Island – we read it aloud to our kids, as an elementary school teacher once did for me, I’m quite sure (but don’t remember which one).

My Young Adult Contemporary Novel choices were solid choices, but The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants is the one I’d most like to reread. (And its eaudio version is available without a wait.)

As for the Young Adult and Children’s Classic Rereads, well, I did a project (unfinished) to reread all of L. M. Montgomery’s books in 2019 before an incredible visit to her home in Prince Edward Island.

Probably my favorite review I’ve written – at least my favorite of the ones I’ve revisited – is my “Reflections on Winnie-the-Pooh,” about how that book has been an important part of my life for decades.

In Children’s Nonfiction, which you’ll notice isn’t my favorite category, I still believe that Greg Tang’s The Best of Times is a vital resource for teaching kids to think about how multiplication works, beyond just memorizing facts. It’s still in print, and I recently ordered fresh copies for our library system.

In Fiction for Grown-ups, the top two are two of my favorite authors. I read The Sand-Reckoner, by Gillian Bradshaw, for my 2001 Revisit, so I’m going to hold off on rereading Cleopatra’s Heir. And Quentins, by Maeve Binchy, is another one I’m now wanting to revisit.
To this day, the title Five Quarters of the Orange, by Joanne Harris, makes me think of driving through the French countryside to Paris (when I was reading it) and the amazing chocolate shop we found there. Okay, the review says I read Chocolat on that particular trip. But anyway, Joanne Harris transports me to France.

All the Fiction Rereads are All-Time Favorites, and it was Caravan that I chose as the one book to revisit from 2002 – with a bit of disappointment I’m afraid. The other three are, you guessed it, available as eaudiobooks, and I’ve already started in on Watership Down.

For Biographical Nonfiction, again it’s the top two that I would dearly love to reread (I own both) – Angles of Reflection, by Joan Richards, and In Code, by Sarah Flannery. The rest were good, but the one I’d be most interested in rereading from those is #7, Bringing Down the House, by Ben Mezrich.

But the Biographical Reread? Oh, I need to pick up Life Among the Savages, by Shirley Jackson, (which I own) to give myself some good hard laughs and a renewed outlook.

In Other Nonfiction, Barbara Kingsolver is always good, but I’d probably rather reread her fiction. If I still had kids in my home, A Mind at a Time, by Mel Levine, feels vital. And this project reminded me to pull out my copy of Storybook Travels and now look for sites in America instead of in Europe.

The Other Nonfiction Rereads are all beloved Christian books I’ve read multiple times since writing these reviews. You may have noticed there are a lot of Rereads included? Back when I was doing ezine issues of Sonderbooks, in 2002, I started including an “Old Favorite” with every issue – so I was rereading a beloved book every couple weeks, something I don’t have the luxury to do now that I’m working full-time and reading for award committees. As I was starting Sonderbooks, I wanted to include my all-time favorites, so that gave my reviews a nice foundation.

And that brings us to New Picture Books. I chose these before I was a children’s librarian, and honestly probably the only one today that would still make my list is Hungry Hen – I’m a sucker for picture books where someone bad gets eaten. Or, well, where anyone gets eaten. I was able to find all the books in Fairfax County Public Library (and enjoyed them) except for Elephant elephant, which was a very quirky French import.

So there you have it – My thoughts on revisiting my 2002 Sonderbooks Stand-outs. I hope you’ve found or been reminded of a book to enjoy. They are all well-worth your time.

I’ve already decided on the book to revisit from my 2003 Sonderbooks Stand-outs – Beyond the Limit, by Joan Spicci. But I’ve also put a few of the others in my eaudiobook holds queue. I hope you’ll hear about them in only a few weeks this time, rather than a few months. Until then, Happy Reading!

I’m celebrating my 25th year of writing Sonderbooks with #Sonderbooks25! Tonight I’ll be looking at my 2001 Sonderbooks Stand-outs.

I already talked about my plans for #Sonderbooks25. I’m afraid it’s going to take longer than I thought, especially the first five years, before I switched formats. I’m redoing the format and now the 2001 Sonderbooks Stand-outs page takes you to a phone-friendly page. Here’s the original version. Though I’m afraid all the reviews are still in the original format, better read on a computer.

Now, my plan was to look at all the Sonderbooks Stand-outs reviews and choose one book to reread from each year’s Stand-outs. For 2001, that’s got to be The Sand-Reckoner, by Gillian Bradshaw, from my very first issue of Sonderbooks, and what may have motivated me to finally start writing Sonderbooks because I wanted to tell people about it.

(It’s going to take me a couple weeks to get to read it. I’m doing a program about this year’s book award winners for other librarians on February 19th, and I’m trying to cram as many more award winners as I can before that program.)

But I didn’t realize I’d be compelled to read *all* my reviews and pages from 2001. That was the year I turned 37, so I also reread my Project 52 posts from the year I was 36 and the year I was 37. Yikes! That’s exactly the age my oldest kid is now, in 2025! My kids then turned 13 and 7 in 2001. I was reading to Timothy’s 1st and 2nd grade classrooms every couple weeks, so the picture books I read were more geared to that age. I was still very much in love with my husband, and we were reading books to both kids at bedtime. I was then a big fan of J. K. Rowling – before she revealed herself to be a transphobe.

I began writing Sonderbooks on August 4, 2001 – so the 25th anniversary won’t happen until August 4, 2026 – which gives me time to complete this project! But 2025 is the 25th year I’m choosing Sonderbooks Stand-outs, so it seems good to start celebrating!

Sonderbooks began as an email newsletter – an “ezine” I called it. Based on the fact that all the early pages have “Copyright 2003” at the bottom – I think I didn’t make it a website until 2003.  I was working half-time at Sembach Base Library in Germany, while my husband was stationed with the USAFE Band.

So because it was an ezine, I’d write five or six reviews all at the same time, every week or two (Really! I was only working part-time then and working at a library got me reading a lot. No TV because we only got German TV.) – and the reviews were a lot shorter than what I write now, each for their own page. Here’s a page of all the Back Issues of Sonderbooks. In 2001, beginning in August, I wrote the first 18 issues.

Some interesting things about those early issues:

On Sonderbooks #7, I started posting an Old Favorite with every issue. Now that I was writing about books, I wanted to mention the books I’d come back to time and time again. I didn’t necessarily reread them for the issue, but it looks like posting about them usually got me to go back and reread them. But there were so many great books I reread in 2001 because of that, I gave them separate listings in the 2001 Sonderbooks Stand-outs.  [And I want to reread them ALL again now!]

I also posted a Picture Book Pick every issue – but wasn’t as careful about designating which were favorites I’d been reading to my kids for years and which were new. The 2001 Sonderbooks only listed new picture books from 2001 – so I didn’t honor the beloved books The Three Little Wolves and the Big Bad Pig, Rainy Morning or Clever Cat.

Reading through the back issues, I do think I did a good job picking Stand-outs – as those are the ones that still stand out in my mind 25 years later. I had forgotten that of course, shortly after beginning Sonderbooks, September 11 happened. So there were some books about that, and a book about Saddam Hussein and a book about the Taliban.  Little did we know what was to come.  I don’t find myself wanting to reread those.

Something I miss from the old ezines is that starting with Sonderbooks #9, I put a Quotation of the Week at the end of each issue, a quotation from that week’s reading. (This later evolved into my Sonderquotes blog.) By far my favorite from the first batch of Quotations is the one from Sonderbooks #17:

“Always my days have seemed to me too short to achieve my desire.”
–Aragorn, in The Return of the King, by J. R. R. Tolkien

I keep chanting that to myself as I’m staying up too late – and I feel suddenly noble of purpose instead of just someone who’s trying to do too much.

For the Stand-outs – there were so many “Old Favorites” that I still love so much! I want to reread them all! (Though most I’ve read again sometime since 2001.)

And there were some new favorites that I didn’t remember I’d discovered in 2001 – notably The Thief and The Queen of Attolia, by Megan Whalen Turner; Enchantress from the Stars, by Sylvia Louise Engdahl; and Dark Lord of Derkholm and Year of the Griffin, by Diana Wynne Jones.  Yes, I’ve read those again in the time since.

That was when I loved reading memoirs about moving to a place with another culture, and I gave those books their own section on the 2001 Sonderbooks Stand-outs page, beginning with Extra Virgin, by Annie Hawes. I want to read more of those again! And that reminds me – many of my favorite books from 2001, I’d read before I started writing Sonderbooks, so they never did get reviews, and the link just goes to their Amazon listing. Now I’d love to read all of those and give them a review!

A nonfiction book that stuck with me all those years and I still think about frequently is Suburban Nation. It explains why your typical suburban neighborhood, built for cars instead of people, doesn’t feel inviting to pedestrians (and why places built like German villages do – though they didn’t use those words).

And probably still the best travel book I’ve ever read is For the Love of Ireland. That was the year we got to spend three weeks and traveled all around Ireland – and for me the trip was accompanied by stories and essays from each region, thanks to this book. It made me feel like I was going deeper. I want to read the book again – though then I may be compelled to go back to Ireland.

I did reread all the picture books listed in the Stand-outs – they are all still available in my library. And they all still bring me a smile. Well, except maybe The Three Golden Keys. Maybe I was in too much of a hurry when I read it this time? I suspect I loved it in 2001 because that was also the year I got to hear Peter Sis speak at a writer’s conference in Paris. So I was well-disposed to love his book. My favorite picture book this time around was probably The Three Pigs – and I’m proud that we discovered it before it won the Caldecott Medal, so our family copy has no medal on the cover.

So yes!  Those are my thoughts on celebrating my 25th year of writing Sonderbooks by revisiting the reviews I wrote in 2001 and my 2001 Sonderbooks Stand-outs.

What were you reading in 2001?  Have you read any of my Stand-outs?