Review of Bookshops & Bonedust, by Travis Baldree

Audiobooks, Fantasy, Fiction Review, Starred Review 0

Bookshops & Bonedust

by Travis Baldree
read by the Author

Macmillan Audio, 2023. 8 hours, 24 minutes.
Review written March 27, 2026, from a library eaudiobook.
Starred review

I have discovered my new favorite genre! Okay, I’ve already read lots of books in this genre and loved them, but when I read a Writer’s Digest interview with this author and heard his books described as “Cozy Fantasy,” I knew I would like them. I was completely correct.

In fact, I think the adult Cozy Fantasy genre is exactly what I liked about Young Adult Fantasy when I started writing Sonderbooks 25 years ago. Okay, the current Cozy Fantasy has a little more sex, but not super graphic sex. Current Young Adult Fantasy has gotten a lot darker, in general, as well as getting sexier, and I still enjoy it, but it’s a little harder to find stories I love. I also sympathize a whole lot less with tropes like the good and noble prince with a terribly evil father ruling, but the prince falls in love with a commoner oppressed by his father. Or other tropes that I’ve seen before which aren’t so wonderfully healthy if you think about them very long. Cozy Fantasy, though, currently seems like a good bet I’ll like it. (Anyway, I’m going to test that out and search for Cozy Fantasy and see how long that lasts.) 25 years ago or so, I said I didn’t like adult fantasy too much because it was mostly epic quests and detailed world-building, and I preferred young adult fantasy which had a mythic element, simpler with a fairy-tale feeling. (I still love fairy tale retellings.) It seems to me that Cozy Fantasy has recaptured that simplicity, throwing a dash of magic into a world you might want to live in.

Okay, so this book is actually a prequel – described as #0 in the series by Libby – and I decided to read it first. I was completely charmed and will queue up to read the rest of his books. (And the author does a great job reading it.)

Our main character is Viv, an orc who works as a mercenary with an elite group of rangers chasing down a necromancer. In the prologue, she gets out ahead of her group, fighting and slaying some wights – when one of them gives her a severe leg wound. Viv has to stay in one place to recover, so she’s in a quiet sea village waiting for the rangers to come back for her.

As an orc, Viv’s an imposing figure, but Fern, the ratkin who owns the village bookshop, dares to recommend a novel to Viv – and a friendship is born, as well as a new habit for Viv. Fern’s bookshop, which she inherited from her father, is cluttered, has a smelly rug, and is in general disrepair. Viv helps Fern spruce things up and revive her business.

But while that is happening, someone comes to the village with the smell of death. Some articles owned by the necromancer turn up in their town, and it’s no surprise to the reader when the battle with the necromancer comes to Viv before she’s necessarily ready.

But most of the story is about the characters and relationships. Enough so that we’re super concerned for everyone in the village when the big showdown happens.

I do love the way an orc who turns out to love to read is our main character. Okay, she is a skilled mercenary, but there’s a lot more to her than that. I was completely charmed by this book and ready to read the other books about Viv and Fern reunited years later (with Viv married to a succubus) in another town. Cozy fantasy is the perfect way to describe this.

travisbaldree.com

Buy from Amazon.com

Find this review on Sonderbooks at: www.sonderbooks.com/Fiction/bookshops_and_bonedust.html

Disclosure: I am an Amazon Affiliate, and will earn a small percentage if you order a book on Amazon after clicking through from my site.

Disclaimer: I am a professional librarian, but the views expressed are solely my own, and in no way represent the official views of my employer or of any committee or group of which I am part.

Subscribe for more reviews and talk about books.

Join the conversation: What did you think of this book?

Review of Maggie; Or, A Man and a Woman Walk into a Bar, by Katie Yee

Audiobooks, Contemporary, Fiction Review 0

Maggie;

Or,

A Man and a Woman Walk into a Bar

by Katie Yee
read by Emily Woo Zeller

Simon & Schuster Audio, 2025. 6 hours, 48 minutes.
Review written March 17, 2026, from a library eaudiobook.

If I had realized this was a novel about a woman whose husband had an affair, I think I would have been smart enough to avoid it. As it was, I’m pretty sure I put this book in my eaudiobook holds queue because a friend of mine read it and loved it. But then it just so happened that I began listening to it on the very day 21 years after I discovered my then-husband was cheating on me.

So I can’t give this audiobook a rational, balanced review. Instead, I’m going to put in brackets the things it brought up in me. And just go with that.

I did listen to the whole book. I did enjoy the characters. I do think the book is well-written. I do realize that unhappy marriages are all unhappy in their own way and that every divorce is different. But there were still some things that really didn’t ring true for me.

Our protagonist and narrator of this book is a Chinese American woman who met her husband in a bar. Ever since she realized that her two children think that she isn’t as funny as their dad, she has been trying to learn to be funnier and to tell jokes.

And then her husband takes her out to a nice place and says, “I’m having an affair.” The other woman’s name is Maggie.

[My first big contrast is that, on that day 21 years before, my husband confessed with the words, “I’m not having an affair.” You see, I had found out that he had been at the other woman’s house after he got home from a work trip at midnight. He confessed to that – but said it wasn’t an affair. That he “needed a friend” and was spending time with her, had watched a movie together at her house at midnight. I believed him! I was used to believing my husband. A year and a half later of gaslighting and lying and mind games, he confessed that it had been an affair all along.]

Our protagonist has a best friend she talks things out with. [Yes! This is vital!] Her obsession with the other woman – stalking her on social media – rings true. [Thank goodness my husband’s affair happened before Facebook was a thing.]

Shortly after, she learns she has cancer. That rings true. I know of many women who have come down with ailments after emotional trauma. [I had a “non-healing wound” on my cervix and had surgery to remove uterine adhesions. My husband reluctantly brought the kids to see me one time during my week in the hospital.]

She names the tumor “Maggie.” I did think that was funny. The book is supposed to be about finding humor in bleak situations, which I appreciate, but it still comes out a little bleak. She didn’t tell her husband or kids about the cancer, only her best friend – which she is fortunately able to pull off.

I do appreciate finding humor and hope in tough times, and the power of friendship and laughter. But I probably shouldn’t read books about affairs any more than I should read books about librarians – it’s too easy for things to feel a bit off.

For example, how was she not curious about when he managed to spend the time with Maggie? How did her mind not circle over and over again around what she now knew were thousands of lies he had told? An affair does require thousands of lies for a moderately connected couple. Even the fact that he told her about it when she wasn’t a bit suspicious doesn’t ring true. From what I’ve read about affairs, it’s more common for a man to say the marriage is bad and leave first – and then pretend that he met the other woman after they separated. [Some good books that could have added realism to the situation are The Script, by Elizabeth Landers and Vicky Mainzer; NOT “Just Friends,” by Shirley P. Glass; and Runaway Husbands, by Vikki Stark.] What’s more, statistically, only 3% to 7% of men who have affairs go on to marry the affair partner, and 75% of those marriages don’t last. But her husband is making plans to be with Maggie. Maggie, I don’t foresee happiness for you with that cheater!

The protagonist was also surprisingly uncurious about how she would survive financially. She was a stay-at-home mother and didn’t seem to worry about keeping that up. Her husband was rich and there was mention of a generous settlement and that she could keep the house. She did look into the fact that she could stay on his health insurance for three years. Maybe she was okay because she went along with everything and let the divorce happen quickly? [In The Script, I learned that my situation was common – early on, while he’s still feeling guilty, the husband says he’ll take care of you, but as time goes on that looks like less and less actual support.] The book ended only a year after the announcement, so we didn’t get to see how she was going to start answering those questions.

But the other really big thing was that although this protagonist did have self-doubt because her all-American blond and blue-eyed husband found a woman who looked like him, there were no recriminations from her husband explaining how his affair was all her fault. [I personally would have thought that was just something that happened in my marriage because I was a just a bad wife, as my husband said I was – except that, thank goodness, I read The Script and learned it’s incredibly common for a man having an affair to convince himself and his wife that it is all her fault. That he had to turn to someone else. None of that in this book. Which made it less painful. But it also felt a bit unrealistic. They were nice to each other, as if an affair is just an unfortunate thing that happened to him – he got a woman Maggie, and she got a tumor Maggie. And maybe that’s healthier?]

[So, good grief, it’s been TWENTY-ONE YEARS!!! Am I not over this yet? Can’t I read a book blending a divorce with humor and not have it all come flooding back?

Added to the mix is that I’d been scheduled to actually see my ex-husband the day I started listening to the book. We’ve each been putting up our oldest adult child for a time and we were going to meet to have them switch homes. Something came up to put it off a week, but that had put the incident on my mind to start with.

But I have to add: I am in a VERY good place in my life. I love my job – feel like it’s what I was born to do. And I never would have gotten it if my husband hadn’t left me – I most likely would have never gotten my Master’s in Library Science and would have continued to work part-time. I have wonderful friends around me and meaningful pursuits and life is very good. At this point, I’m glad I’m not married to him anymore. But despite all that, reading a book about divorce on the anniversary of the day my life fell apart brings up some things.]

So for me, the initial breakup of my marriage was much, much worse than portrayed in this book, although at least I didn’t have cancer along with it. But I have surely gotten a happy ending out of it, and I’m confident this character will, too.

I know, this “review” wasn’t all that much about the book. You can consider this a trigger warning if you’re divorced. I do believe that good writing stirs emotions – and this book certainly did that for me. And here’s to coming through tough times with humor.

katieyee.net

Buy from Amazon.com

Find this review on Sonderbooks at: www.sonderbooks.com/Fiction/maggie.html

Disclosure: I am an Amazon Affiliate, and will earn a small percentage if you order a book on Amazon after clicking through from my site.

Disclaimer: I am a professional librarian, but the views expressed are solely my own, and in no way represent the official views of my employer or of any committee or group of which I am part.

Subscribe for more reviews and talk about books.

Join the conversation: What did you think of this book?

Review of The Summer War, by Naomi Novik

Fantasy, Fiction Review, Starred Review 0

The Summer War

by Naomi Novik

Del Rey, 2025. 127 pages.
Review written March 11, 2026, from a library book.
Starred Review

This is a novella by fantasy master Naomi Novik – so it’s about the same length as the children’s books I often read. Naomi Novik doesn’t need much time pulling you into her fantasy worlds. The book begins:

Celia was twelve years old on the day she cursed her brother.

The book reminded me of Robin McKinley’s The Hero and the Crown [and this is a high compliment!], because it begins with a long section about the past, how Celia grew up alienated from others and didn’t have magic. But the day she cursed her brother – for suddenly leaving her, and not caring – was the day she discovered her magic. She hadn’t known her curse would be effective, but the emotion and passion behind the curse awakened the strong magic within her.

After the explanation of this incident, we hear about the Summer War between humans and the summerlings, who live in the Summer Kingdom. The war went on for a hundred years, but Celia’s father, a general, supposedly stopped it with his tactics. Now the king is wary of him, but Celia’s father is also mourning the departure of his oldest son, and Celia and her remaining brother must keep things going.

But the main action of the book happens when Celia is fifteen. [This book could very well have been published for young adults. The only reason I can think that it wasn’t was to attract Naomi Novik’s existing fans.] She gets drawn into the Summer Kingdom and there is danger of the Summer War starting up again, and many are in peril, and the mess requires great skill and cleverness to solve. And Celia would like to break her brother’s curse as well.

This is a quick read, but it’s full of magic and the otherworldly, and it showcases Naomi Novik’s magical weaving of worlds.

naominovik.com

Buy from Amazon.com

Find this review on Sonderbooks at: www.sonderbooks.com/Fiction/summer_war.html

Disclosure: I am an Amazon Affiliate, and will earn a small percentage if you order a book on Amazon after clicking through from my site.

Disclaimer: I am a professional librarian, but the views expressed are solely my own, and in no way represent the official views of my employer or of any committee or group of which I am part.

Subscribe for more reviews and talk about books.

Join the conversation: What did you think of this book?

Review of A Witch’s Guide to Magical Innkeeping, by Sangu Mandanna

Audiobooks, Fantasy, Fiction Review, Starred Review 0

A Witch’s Guide to Magical Innkeeping

by Sangu Mandanna
read by Samara MacLaren

Books on Tape, 2025. 9 hours, 53 minutes.
Review written February 23, 2026, from a library eaudiobook.
Starred Review

I think this audiobook was suggested to me after I finished Sarah Beth Durst’s latest. If so, the recommendation was spot-on. This is also a cozy fantasy story with all kinds of feel-good vibes.

At 15 years old, Sera Swan was one of the two most powerful witches in Britain. But she was an outsider because she wasn’t from a long-standing British magical family. So when she uses up her magic to bring her great-aunt back from death, instead of other witches helping her get it back, she’s put in exile from all magic society.

Fifteen years later, Sera is making do with only a tiny bit of magic. She’s running the inn with her great-aunt, protected by the spell she performed as a child – only allowing those who truly need the inn to find it. They’ve assembled a hodge-podge family of sorts – an overeager elderly lady, a young man who works at the Renaissance Fair and calls himself her knight, and Sera’s young cousin Theo who is learning the fundamentals of magic – and letting Sera read the more advanced texts he checks out. And then there’s Clemmie, the witch who turned herself into a fox when a curse backfired. She wants Sera to regain her power and restore her as well.

And now it looks like Sera may be able to restore her power. With the help of the powerful Restoration spell – and the handsome librarian who has shown up at the inn, needing a place for his young sister, who is a witch but is also autistic and doesn’t always follow the rules. But then there’s the matter of figuring out the ingredients of the spell.

This is a delightfully cozy story with a clear progression of tasks for Sera, but some setbacks and plot twists along the way. I found myself loving the assortment of characters at the inn – while hating the villain who is indeed despicable but powerful. I wish I could find my way to this magical inn, but enjoying through the book was perfect.

sangumandanna.com

Buy from Amazon.com

Find this review on Sonderbooks at: www.sonderbooks.com/Fiction/witchs_guide_to_magical_innkeeping.html

Disclosure: I am an Amazon Affiliate, and will earn a small percentage if you order a book on Amazon after clicking through from my site.

Disclaimer: I am a professional librarian, but the views expressed are solely my own, and in no way represent the official views of my employer or of any committee or group of which I am part.

Subscribe for more reviews and talk about books.

Join the conversation: What did you think of this book?

Review of The Magician of Tiger Castle, by Louis Sachar

Audiobooks, Fantasy, Fiction Review, Starred Review 0

The Magician of Tiger Castle

by Louis Sachar
read by Edoardo Ballerini

Books on Tape, 2025. 7 hours, 17 minutes.
Review written February 12, 2026, from a library eaudiobook.
Starred Review

Louis Sachar has written a book for adults!

Louis Sachar is the Newbery-winning author of Holes and the Wayside School books, both of which I read before I started writing Sonderbooks. (I do have a review up of his 2010 book, The Cardturner.) From those books, I already knew he’s especially good at intricate, clever plots – and yes, that’s a way this book shines as well.

By the time my hold came in on this audiobook, I’d forgotten it was for adults, and just saw it was a Louis Sachar book. So I was a bit surprised when the main character was a man in his forties. After said main character was surprisingly frank about some bodily functions (nothing crude, just surprising if you thought it was a children’s book) – I remembered it was his first novel for adults.

The book begins with Anatole sipping tea at a cafe in front of a castle that keeps a tiger in the moat. As he talks about what the tour guide is saying to a group, we begin to realize he knows a lot more about the castle than he should. And then he launches into the story of how the first tiger came to the castle in the 16th Century as a betrothal gift to the princess of Esquaveta (which was the small country the castle ruled then) in preparation for the wedding of the century.

Anatole was then the royal magician. He didn’t cast spells, but he was exceptionally skilled at mixing potions. As the wedding approached, Princess Tullia declared that she was not going to marry the prince of a neighboring country because she’d fallen in love with her tutor. The tutor was now in the dungeon, and the king tasked Anatole with making the princess go through with the marriage and saving Esquavita from the neighboring kingdom’s powerful army.

And that’s the story that follows. At first, Anatole simply plans to fulfill the king’s command. He’ll make a potion to make the two lovebirds forget all about each other. But he needs to get close to the prisoner in order to get a heartfelt tear for the potion – and that involves getting to know him. And things get much more complicated than they seem at first.

So this is a fantasy story – Anatole is very good at making potions, and we appreciate all the work and experimentation he puts into making it just right. This is no romantasy – but we do come to care about the princess and the prisoner, and there is definitely a romantic subplot – even if their love must first be thwarted. As I mentioned, this author is particularly good at plotting, and he had me intent on the story every step of the way.

Yes, adults who read and loved Holes as kids are going to love this, too. It’s a completely different story, but it does appeal to the same part of my brain that loves a tightly constructed plot with characters you can’t help but care about.

louissachar.com

Buy from Amazon.com

Find this review on Sonderbooks at: www.sonderbooks.com/Fiction/magician_of_tiger_castle.html

Disclosure: I am an Amazon Affiliate, and will earn a small percentage if you order a book on Amazon after clicking through from my site.

Disclaimer: I am a professional librarian, but the views expressed are solely my own, and in no way represent the official views of my employer or of any committee or group of which I am part.

Subscribe for more reviews and talk about books.

Join the conversation: What did you think of this book?

Review of The Enchanted Greenhouse, by Sarah Beth Durst, by Caitlin Davies

Fantasy, Fiction Review, Starred Review 0

The Enchanted Greenhouse

by Sarah Beth Durst
read by Caitlin Davies

Macmillan Audio, 2025. 13 hours, 33 minutes.
Review written February 7, 2026, from a library eaudiobook.
Starred Review

The Enchanted Greenhouse is another cozy fantasy romance from Sarah Beth Durst, set in the same world as The Spellshop. Though this book was written after The Spellshop, I think you’d be able to read the books in any order. And if you enjoy one, you’ll enjoy the other. I was delighted to learn the origin of the sentient spider plant who was the friend of the main character in the first book.

However, enchanting that spider plant into life got our main character, Terlu, into deep trouble. She was a librarian in the Great Library of Alyssium, the Empire’s capital city, and she got lonely in the stacks with no one to talk to. So she enchanted a spider plant to keep her company. But the law declared that only sorcerers were allowed to do magic. Terlu was discovered and found guilty – and condemned to be a statue in the Great Library as a warning to others.

But then Terlu wakes up in a snowy forest. She’s not a statue any more. She goes searching for others and finds a giant enchanted greenhouse, with many smaller greenhouses inside of it, full of wonders. There is one gardener on the island in charge of it all. He’d expected that the statue he’d been sent and awoken was a sorcerer to help him solve the problem of the greenhouses failing after the death of the sorcerer who’d created them. Instead he got a librarian who’s afraid to do magic because she doesn’t want to be turned into a statue again.

But it turns out the gardener, Yarrow, is a kind man (and handsome!) and he gives her food and shelter for as long as she wants to stay. And then Terlu waters and awakens a small sentient rose plant who had been dormant. And this rose convinces her to seek a spell to awaken her fellow sentient plants who are all in an enchanted sleep. Between that and the failing greenhouses, Terlu realizes that she needs to figure out the old sorcerer’s spells to help these other beings. Fortunately, she’s skilled in multiple languages, though she might need a little help with code-breaking.

That’s the world of this book, and it adds up to another sweet and satisfying cozy magical story.

sarahbethdurst.com

Buy from Amazon.com

Find this review on Sonderbooks at: www.sonderbooks.com/Fiction/enchanted_greenhouse.html

Disclosure: I am an Amazon Affiliate, and will earn a small percentage if you order a book on Amazon after clicking through from my site.

Disclaimer: I am a professional librarian, but the views expressed are solely my own, and in no way represent the official views of my employer or of any committee or group of which I am part.

Subscribe for more reviews and talk about books.

Join the conversation: What did you think of this book?

Review of How to Read a Book, by Monica Wood

Audiobooks, Contemporary, Fiction Review, Starred Review 0

How to Read a Book

by Monica Wood
read by Eileen Stevens

HarperCollins, 2024. 10 hours, 18 minutes.
Review written January 28, 2026, from a library eaudiobook.
Starred Review

First, a great big thank you to my friend Eileen, who recommended this book. I loved it so much!

I mean, what’s not to like? It starts out in a book club in a women’s prison. Violet, who’s 22 years old and was in prison for manslaughter, is remembering how the meetings used to go. The women would find fault with most of the books, but got a lot of satisfaction out of even that.

Then Violet gets out of prison. Her sister picks her up, but shows her an apartment in the city, rent paid for with inheritance money after their mother’s death – which the whole family blames Violet for. Her family doesn’t want her to even come back to their small town.

But in Portland, Maine, Violet runs into Harriet, the lady who ran the book club, in a book store – and also encounters Frank, the man whose wife died when Violet was driving drunk.

One thing leads to another – also involving a job taking care of highly intelligent parrots – and I was super interested all the way, enjoying the company of these kind and wise people. (Well, Violet doesn’t always act wisely, but Harriet and Frank are there to help.)

And of course it’s a book about the power of books to connect people and transform lives. And a book about second chances. And standing up for yourself even after you make bad mistakes.

It’s also the sort of book that expands your heart.

monicawood.com

Buy from Amazon.com

Find this review on Sonderbooks at: www.sonderbooks.com/Fiction/how_to_read_a_book.html

Disclosure: I am an Amazon Affiliate, and will earn a small percentage if you order a book on Amazon after clicking through from my site.

Disclaimer: I am a professional librarian, but the views expressed are solely my own, and in no way represent the official views of my employer or of any committee or group of which I am part.

Subscribe for more reviews and talk about books.

Join the conversation: What did you think of this book?

Review of The Lost Bookshop, by Evie Woods

Audiobooks, Contemporary, Fiction Review, Historical, Paranormal, Romance 0

The Lost Bookshop

by Evie Woods
read by Avena Mansergh-Wallace, Olivia Mace, and Nick Biadon

One More Chapter (HarperCollins), 2023. 12 hours, 1 minute.
Review written December 26, 2025, from a library eaudiobook.

I put a hold on The Lost Bookshop because of how much I enjoyed the author’s The Mysterious Bakery on Rue de Paris. This one was very similar, and I also enjoyed it. In both, we’ve got one historical thread combined with a romance in the present, and the perspectives of both the man and woman involved in the romance, plus the perspective of the character in history whose actions affect the present.

Our characters in this book start with Opaline, in the early twentieth century, whose brother was forcing her to marry a man she hadn’t even met after their father died. Opaline flees to Paris, and there starts working with Sylvia Beach in the famous Shakespeare & Co. bookshop. She later moves to Dublin and starts her own bookshop – until her brother gets her committed to an insane asylum.

In the present, we’ve got Martha, who’s fleeing her abusive husband and looking for a job in Dublin. She lands a job as a housekeeper for an eccentric old woman in a historic home. Then one day she sees Henry scrutinizing her windows and thinks he’s a peeping Tom. But he is looking for a bookshop with an address right next to her house – that doesn’t seem to exist. But Henry is a rare book dealer and has a letter that says that bookshop has Emily Bronte’s lost second manuscript.

One thing leads to another, and you can tell where it’s going – but it’s fun. Opaline’s story – in Paris and especially in the insane asylum – is riveting.

I have to say that this book had more paranormal elements than The Mysterious Bakery on Rue de Paris – and for me this one crossed the line into unbelievability. It wasn’t only the bookshop that only appears to those who need it (or true believers? or something), but also mysterious otherworldly messages, and several more things.

However, despite a few too many paranormal bits for my taste – I still enjoyed these characters. Henry always seems to say the wrong thing, but he’s earnest and kind. Martha fleeing a truly horrible abusive situation had all my sympathy as well. (I saw my ex-husband for the first time in a decade when I was in the middle of listening to this book and was reminded of how we program ourselves to love someone, and that’s hard to turn off, even when their behavior means they don’t deserve or want your love any more. Not that mine was as bad as Martha’s husband. But still, she had my sympathy.) And Opaline’s situation was also fascinating in an awful way, tying in with what I’d read in Ten Days a Madwoman, by Deborah Noyes. It wasn’t all that long ago that men could lock women up in insane asylums.

Fortunately, this story ends happily for all our main characters. This is a feel-good romance, a little too enthusiastic with the paranormal elements, but you can be sure that all the stars align for them in the end.

eviewoods.com

Buy from Amazon.com

Find this review on Sonderbooks at: www.sonderbooks.com/Fiction/lost_bookshop.html

Disclosure: I am an Amazon Affiliate, and will earn a small percentage if you order a book on Amazon after clicking through from my site.

Disclaimer: I am a professional librarian, but the views expressed are solely my own, and in no way represent the official views of my employer or of any committee or group of which I am part.

Subscribe for more reviews and talk about books.

Join the conversation: What did you think of this book?

Review of Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell, by Susanna Clarke

Fantasy, Fiction Review, Sonderbooks25, Stand-outs, Starred Review 0

Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell

by Susanna Clarke
read by Simon Prebble

Macmillan Audio, 2006. 32 hours, 30 minutes.
Review written November 24, 2025, from a library eaudiobook.
Originally reviewed October 26, 2004.
Starred Review
2004 Sonderbooks Stand-out: #1 Science Fiction and Fantasy

I reread (via listening) this book as part of my celebration of #Sonderbooks25 – my 25th year of writing Sonderbooks. Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell was my favorite new book for adults that I read in 2004.

I’m sorry to say that I wasn’t as enamored with the book as when I read it the first time – it’s definitely not my favorite book of the year this year, or even close. But I still thoroughly enjoyed revisiting the story and getting caught up in Susanna Clarke’s highly detailed alternate world. Let me talk about the good things, but also why I’m not raving about it this time around.

The book is long. The first time I read it, the only way I could bring myself to tackle it was one chapter per day while I read other books – until I got about halfway through and was more obsessed. This time around, it required two separate checkouts of the eaudiobook, with a wait in between. 32 hours! But the length is also a strength. The incredible detail – with footnotes! – of the alternate-reality England during the Napoleonic Wars is an incredible feat of world-building. Simon Prebble feels like the perfect reader for the book, reading it with the voice of a scholarly old gentleman that just suits the story perfectly.

The story takes you through first Mr. Norrell and then Jonathan Strange being the first practical magicians that England has seen in hundreds of years. We’ve got hints about the Raven King, who used to control magic in England. We’re warned about the Faery realms and see the drastic consequences when Mr. Norrell messes with fairies – but consequences that he keeps secret from everyone else. We watch those consequences play out, and we watch Jonathan Strange do magic to win the war with Napoleon – and then diverge from his teacher. And eventually, we watch the prophecy happen about the two of them bringing magic back to England. And always a nefarious fairy causing trouble behind the scenes.

The book is immersive, and listening was a great way for me to tolerate the great length. So why was I not as enraptured this time around?

First, I already knew about the amazing world-building, so I took it more for granted this time. I did notice this time the blatant racism and anti-Semitism. It probably accurately reflects attitudes in England at that time, but was still unpleasant to read about. And there was a “historical” story told about the magic of Native Americans – including footnotes – that felt like a demeaning caricature. So I do feel like I should warn about that.

But I also realized that I didn’t remember how it ended – and was kind of let down when it did. Yes, many threads come together, but I didn’t think the ending was terribly satisfying. And then I realized that I didn’t really like any of the characters much. So the world-building and the delightful scholarly tone is the best part of the book. And they do carry the book the entire 32 hours, but it wasn’t quite as wonderful as I had remembered.

All the same, if you’re ever in the mood for a great big doorstopper of a fantasy novel that is not a romantasy but does present an amazing alternate world of magic – Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell is worth reading. And, yes, rereading.

Buy from Amazon.com

Find this review on Sonderbooks at: www.sonderbooks.com/Fiction/jonathan_strange_and_mr_norrell.html

Disclosure: I am an Amazon Affiliate, and will earn a small percentage if you order a book on Amazon after clicking through from my site.

Disclaimer: I am a professional librarian, but the views expressed are solely my own, and in no way represent the official views of my employer or of any committee or group of which I am part.

Subscribe for more reviews and talk about books.

Join the conversation: What did you think of this book?

Review of We’ll Prescribe You a Cat, by Syou Ishida

Audiobooks, Contemporary, Fiction Review, Starred Review 0

We’ll Prescribe You a Cat

by Syou Ishida
translated by E. Madison Shimoda
read by Naruto Komatsu and Natsumi Kuroda

Books on Tape, 2024. 7 hours, 8 minutes.
Review written January 2, 2026, from a library eaudiobook.
Starred Review

There seems to be a new genre of books being written in Japan: A quirky place where people from disparate lives go to receive something that changes their lives. It’s a charming and lovely genre, but since this is the third such book I’ve read in three months, I think I need a break from them to more fully appreciate the charm.

The first such book I read, at the recommendation of my friend Suzanne, who subscribes to Book Talking with Sondy, was What You Are Looking For Is in the Library, by Michiko Aoyama. I was utterly charmed. So when the reviews on Libby said that it was similar to Before the Coffee Gets Cold, I put that one on hold. Then my sister Wendy, who has lived in Japan in the past, told me she was reading What You Are Looking for Is in the Library and loving it – and that it reminded her of the book We’ll Subscribe You a Cat. So I immediately put this book on hold. I indeed enjoyed it very much – but do feel I need a break from this genre for a bit.

This one has a stronger paranormal element than the other two, even the time-traveling Before the Coffee Gets Cold. There’s a “Clinic for the Soul” in part of Kyoto that people can only find if they’re specifically looking for it (and sometimes not even then). It’s run by one doctor and one unfriendly nurse. And after the doctor listens to the patient’s troubles, he prescribes them a cat. He writes a prescription and they take it to the reception desk and get a cat in a carrier, and some gear and food to care for the cat for a specific number of days.

The book is about several people with very different lives who come to the clinic and whose lives are transformed by the cat they are prescribed.

I still like the book featuring a library the best of the books in this genre. Perhaps I was a bit defensive, because I no way no how want to adopt a cat myself. And rolled my eyes a little at how easily a spouse’s cat allergy was resolved with medication. But other than that, it was another delightful and charming book. I think cat lovers will love it as much as I loved the book about the mystical library.

There were some surprises – like the way the man who had trouble with insomnia and bad dreams about his new supervisor was cured by the cat keeping him up all night. None of the cat cures was completely predictable, in fact. And the different ways the prescriptions play out makes for interesting storytelling.

As with the other books mentioned here, this is a feel-good story that will certainly leave you with some smiles.

Buy from Amazon.com

Find this review on Sonderbooks at: www.sonderbooks.com/Fiction/well_prescribe_you_a_cat.html

Disclosure: I am an Amazon Affiliate, and will earn a small percentage if you order a book on Amazon after clicking through from my site.

Disclaimer: I am a professional librarian, but the views expressed are solely my own, and in no way represent the official views of my employer or of any committee or group of which I am part.

Subscribe for more reviews and talk about books.

Join the conversation: What did you think of this book?