Category: Starred Review

This Is Not That Kind of Book

written by Christopher Healy
illustrated by Ben Mantle

Random House, 2019. 36 pages.
Review written September 3, 2020, from a library book
Starred Review

Here’s a fun picture book that plays with a meta-narrative and gets kids thinking about genre and storytelling.

The book starts with “A is for apple.” But Little Red Riding Hood, who’s portrayed with dark skin, interrupts. She says, “Hey! This is not an alphabet book! Sorry, this is a fairy tale. Come see.” And she leads us to the next page.

All through the book, the Apple-with-a-face only says one thing: “I’m an apple!” On Red Riding Hood’s page, she invites it into her basket.

They see a shape in the shadows. Little Red Riding Hood tells the Letter A, “It’s going to be a wolf. I’m very familiar with this type of story.”

However, when we turn the page – it’s a giant robot!

And new characters show up with every page turn, with their own opinions about what kind of book this is – and isn’t. My favorite is probably the banana named Captain Knock-Knock from a joke book.

Finally, Little Red Riding Hood explores outside the book and learns from the back cover:

This is a book about a group of characters who have nothing in common, but who work together to figure out what kind of book they’re in.

And the odd assortment of characters end up making friends. And it’s all very silly and delightful and gets kids thinking about they types of books they read.

Because of the meta-narrative, this edges toward early elementary kids more than preschoolers. But it will get any child thinking about stories and about how books work, which builds their early literacy skills.

christopherhealy.com

Buy from Amazon.com

Disclosure: I am an Amazon Affiliate, and will earn a small percentage if you order a book on Amazon after clicking through from my site.

Disclaimer: I am a professional librarian, but the views expressed are solely my own, and in no way represent the official views of my employer or of any committee or group of which I am part.

What did you think of this book?

*Note* To try to catch up on posting reviews, I’m posting the oldest reviews I’ve written on my blog without making a page on my main website. They’re still good books!

I Do Not Eat Children

by Marcus Cutler

Little, Brown and Company, 2024. 36 pages.
Review written March 4, 2024, from a library book.
Starred Review

The second I saw the cover of this book, I knew our library needed many copies. I’m afraid I do like picture books about things (or, yes people) getting eaten. So much so, I made a Pinterest board “Someone Gets Eaten,” with a companion board, “Eating Thwarted.”

Okay, stop right now if you don’t like spoilers for picture books.

Because for the sake of parents, I need to tell you exactly what’s in this book. First, it does fit the first of those boards.

And this book might have gone just a tiny bit too far, even for me. I think it’s the sweet little chubby baby that might be a step too extreme. But I still think it’s fun and still showed it to co-workers.

And it’s not only a book about a monster! It’s also a counting-down book. The counting isn’t done for you, but on the first spread, you’ve got a monster in the middle of ten children (including the aforementioned baby), all with some kind of prop. The monster says, “I do not eat children.”

On the next page, there’s a child missing. Their prop is in the place where they stood, but you might want to count to be sure there are fewer. Now the monster is saying, “I would never eat a child.” The kids are carrying on with what they were doing, some interacting with each other, but everybody ignoring the monster.

And each spread has one fewer child. More protestations from the monster.

And just when you’re thinking that surely there’s some different explanation, surely the monster is telling the truth and isn’t actually eating the children (and who will save the BABY???!!!), with four children left, the monster gives an enormous BURP that takes up two spreads — and the big green speech bubble includes additional clothes and items we saw from the missing children.

However, after they all disappear one by one and the very last child is left, the only one whose eyes pointed anywhere near the monster — she tells us that she eats liars.

And on the last page, the Monster is missing with his striped pants in his place.

So — Parents, I want you to be aware that this book will be scary for some little ones. Some children do get eaten. Completely off the page. But still.

Now, mind you, that monster gets eaten, too! He totally gets what he deserves! You can also tell your kid that the girl let out all the other children before she ate the monster. (Or you can try.)

So a lot of kids, especially older ones — and most adults — will find this book funny. It’s even a great excuse to practice counting! But you need to judge where your child will fall on that spectrum. I personally wouldn’t try this book in storytime because of that doubt. Which is sort of a shame, because if you can get in the right mindset, it’s a really fun book with lots to notice. And you can teach about unreliable narrators and seeing from someone else’s perspective!

This book reminds me of Lucy Cummins’ A Hungry Lion or: A Dwindling Assortment of Animals, which I wholeheartedly love, and at least that one doesn’t have a baby being eaten. But this one is a whole lot of fun, too — and I still say that cover is unbeatable!

marcuscutler.com
LBYR.com

Buy from Amazon.com

Find this review on Sonderbooks at: www.sonderbooks.com/Picture_Books/i_do_not_eat_children.html

Disclosure: I am an Amazon Affiliate, and will earn a small percentage if you order a book on Amazon after clicking through from my site.

Disclaimer: I am a professional librarian, but the views expressed are solely my own, and in no way represent the official views of my employer or of any committee or group of which I am part.

What did you think of this book?