Escaping Mr. Rochester
by L. L. McKinney
HarperTeen, 2024. 337 pages.
Review written September 4, 2024, from a library book.
If you’ve read my reviews for very long, you probably know that I love retellings and reimaginings. My favorites are the ones where you think, “Oh! That could be what *really* happened!” — telling the same events from a different perspective that casts things in a whole new light.
Now, I also have to confess that as a teen, Jane Eyre was one of my all-time favorite novels. Yes, as a romance. Coming back to it as an adult, especially with the help of retellings, I’m a little horrified by that opinion.
Escaping Mr. Rochester was a reimagining of Jane Eyre, not a retelling. A whole lot of details were changed, but the skeleton of the story was the same. Our main character is Jane Eyre, coming to be a governess to the young ward of Mr. Rochester at Thornfield Hall. Unbeknownst to Jane, Mr. Rochester has locked up his wife Bertha, and is keeping her in the attic, with the help of an elderly servant tending her. Jane hears strange noises that everyone else denies.
All that big picture is the same as in Jane Eyre, but very few of the details match. The Mr. Rochester of this book is simply a villain, through and through. And something of a cardboard one. His motivation for everything he does is to pay gambling debts. Jane is repulsed from the moment she sees him. She finds out about Bertha fairly early on, and the two of them manage to spend time together, lay plans (to escape, of course) – and fall in love. Of course, plans in a house ruled by such a villain don’t always run smoothly.
Don’t get me wrong – the story is a whole lot of fun. I would have enjoyed a few more nods to original. Like meeting Mr. Rochester when he falls from his horse. And him being somewhat more charming to Jane to start, maybe. Of course, I admire in this Jane that she’s not in a hurry to cozy up to her employer and has a great concept of what’s appropriate in that situation. But part of the power of the original is that you really can see how a sheltered Jane would fall for him. This Mr. Rochester was pretty one-dimensional in his evil. Adele, too, in this version didn’t consistently act or talk like a child.
So this book is not up there with my absolute favorite Jane Eyre spin-off, Reader, I Murdered Him, which has the events of the book all happen as portrayed, but show us Adele after she’s grown up and sent to boarding school. And that one shows a more subtly sinister Mr. Rochester.
However, all that said – this was a fun story, using the basic skeleton of Jane Eyre to show us Jane and Bertha outwitting an evil and contemptible Mr. Rochester and ultimately triumphing over him. And yes, there’s an appropriate use of fire.
Find this review on Sonderbooks at: www.sonderbooks.com/Teens/escaping_mr_rochester.html
Disclosure: I am an Amazon Affiliate, and will earn a small percentage if you order a book on Amazon after clicking through from my site.
Disclaimer: I am a professional librarian, but the views expressed are solely my own, and in no way represent the official views of my employer or of any committee or group of which I am part.
What did you think of this book?